Score: 7

"Not too shabby."

submission: Pico Misadventures Part.1

date: July 26, 2009

I see some definite improvements from your older works. The shift between art styles was interesting, and I got a pretty good chuckle from the Electric Avenue chill out scene. All and all not bad all. I think perhaps you should try to work out a more indepth plot, and see where that takes you. Good luck to you.

Score: 7

"I liked it but Charlie summarized this up for me."

submission: Charlie the Unicorn 3

date: April 20, 2009

At the end of the movie when Charlie was being gassed, he says, "Oh, why did I expect any different?" And that's pretty much how I felt about the film. No surprises, which isn't necessarily a bad thing. I can appreciate you staying true to what made people like these cartoons in the first place. However, over the course of three animations, it's time is coming to a close. The first two episodes, I actually got several belly laughs from the content. This last installment merely kept me entertained, which of course is fine, but it's a little disappointing. The sad thing is, this movie had it been released on it's own, would've probably been funnier, but seeing as we have seen these jokes, this premise, and this outcome twice before, it keeps this one from gaining any real traction. Like I said, it was humorous and kept me entertained but I can officially say I hope this is the last of Charlie the Unicorn unless a fresh angle is introduced.

Score: 10

"Brilliant."

submission: Saturday Morning Watchmen

date: March 13, 2009

Everything about it was so flawlessly excecuted. There really isn't much else to say, as I am sure you are well aware of just how good this really is.

Score: 4

"Not bad......."

submission: asdfmovie

date: August 10, 2008

You honestly would have received a higher score if the static sound from your cuts weren't so obnoxiously loud. I had to just stop watching halfway through, as I couldn't manage to hear the dialogue and keep my ears from being destroyed at the same time. From what I saw, it seems like a decent submission. It may be in your best interest to resubmit this with adjustments to the audio.

Score: 7

"Not too shabby."

submission: Welcome To Jokergrounds

date: July 24, 2008

This was quite decent in my opinion. The character design was very nice, although the animation at times was a bit choppy. The sound was also adequate, although the joker sounds and acts just like the Crypt Keeper from Tales from the Crypt. All in all, this is a deserving submission and hope you bring more of your work to newgrounds.

Score: 8

"Simple, yet effective."

submission: Logic

date: April 28, 2008

It takes an immense amount of talent to generate so much interest out of what little material is presented here. This is my third time watching it,(first time in about a year though) and it's still hilarious. Your theories on Ninjas is insightful, as all of those other "Ninja" experts have never even touched on the secret of their power. Also, is it possible to difuse an encounter with a female ninja by just making her laugh and piss her pants? Seems to me, that not too many people whoop ass when they are covered in piss. But then again, I've never tried to fight a homeless person either though.

Score: 10

"How this isn't in the top 50 is beyond me."

submission: The Obvious Threat

date: April 25, 2008

Perhaps it's simply a lack of understanding at how truly difficult 3D animation can sometimes be. Or maybe, some just have a hard time allowing anything that isn't "FLASH" material on to this site. Whatever the case may be, I am completely shocked that this submission isn't sitting firmly in the Newgrounds top 50. Simply amazing work. The lighting was spot on, and even with minimal dialogue, you managed to convey a sense of desperation in the world you created. The integration of 2D and 3D graphics was seemless, and the sound effects added a haunting ambience. Overall, I have to say this is one animation that needs to be revisited by many people. It's just a shame that even a score of 4+ can sometimes result in your work being lost in the shuffle.

Score: 4

"Not bad, but #1?"

submission: Hertog Jan X

date: December 7, 2006

I have to question the integrity of the voters sometimes. Many of the members seem to suffer from lemmings complex. They just seem to vote high on what is popular, or vote high on something because a buddy of theirs made it. I have seen too many quality submissions get overlooked while complete crap is praised. I am not saying this was complete crap. This was actually better than most of similar flashes. But the marks for this were way way too high. For this to be number 1 is a crying shame. Top 50,000 maybe. Top 50, not a chance.

Score: 1

"It's sounds from the internet."

submission: ~ytmnd soundboard~

date: November 29, 2005

Why would I honestly want to listen to a sound board of sounds I have heard thousands of times elsewhere?

Score: 6

"Odd to say the least"

submission: Strike Flyers - Episode 3

date: November 16, 2005

I thought the story was awful. But, I gave this a passing grade because I do see talent in this, but its not my thing personally. A few things to work on. The voice acting wasnt very good, and as I said the story was just sort of...well retarded. But, this is a decent submission and definitly deserves a spot on newgrounds. You have an interesting style, and I would like to see some of your work outside of this series.